Addressing The ‘I’m Here to Teach, Not Babysit’ Fallacy
Teaching in an increasingly complex world
“I’m here to teach kids, not babysit.” It’s a refrain often heard from frustrated educators, a declaration that emphasizes their role as deliverers of knowledge rather than caretakers. On the surface, it’s a fair distinction—teachers are trained to impart curriculum, not to merely manage behavior. But peel back the layers, and this sentiment reveals a deeper, more troubling implication: too often, “teaching” becomes synonymous with talking at students—delivering content in a one-size-fits-all lecture—rather than teaching the child in a way that meets their unique needs.
This mindset, however unintentionally, sidelines the art and science of education in favor of a conveyor-belt approach to learning. It assumes that if the material is presented, the job is done—regardless of whether the student absorbs, understands, or connects with it. But true teaching isn’t about broadcasting information; it’s about reaching the individual child, understanding how they learn, and fostering an environment where they can thrive. To achieve this, educators need a fundamental shift in perspective—from teaching at kids to teaching kids. And that shift hinges on four key areas: communication that connects, cognitive learning strategies, social-emotional strength, and executive functioning.
The Content Trap
The traditional model of education often prioritizes content over connection. Teachers, under pressure from standardized testing and packed curricula, may feel their primary duty is to “cover” material—dates in history, formulas in math, rules in grammar. While content is undeniably important, this approach risks reducing students to passive receptacles rather than active learners. When a teacher says, “I’m here to teach, not babysit,” they might inadvertently signal that their focus is on the subject matter, not the student’s ability to engage with it.
But here’s the reality: a child who doesn’t grasp how to learn—or who feels disconnected, overwhelmed, or misunderstood—won’t retain that content anyway. Teaching the child means stepping beyond the textbook and into the complexity of human development, guided by four critical pillars.
Four Key Skills Every Teacher (And Leader) Must Develop
Every classroom is a tapestry of neurodiversity—students with varying strengths, challenges, and ways of processing the world. Teaching kids, not just at them, demands that educators focus on these four areas to reach every learner effectively:
Communication Skills and Strategies That Connect: Effective teaching starts with how we reach students. This means adapting language, tone, or visuals—like using metaphors for some or clear, step-by-step explanations for others—to ensure every child feels included and capable of understanding. It’s about building bridges between teacher and student, not just delivering a monologue.
Learning and Cognitive Strategies (Conceptual Transfer and Schema Links): Kids learn best when new ideas link to what they already know. Strategies like conceptual transfer—showing how a math principle applies to budgeting—or schema links—organizing information into mental frameworks—make content stick. These tools turn abstract lessons into concrete understanding, fostering deeper learning.
Social-Emotional Strengthening for Resilience and Collaboration: Learning is emotional as well as intellectual. By nurturing social-emotional skills—through group problem-solving or reflective discussions—teachers build resilience to handle setbacks and collaboration skills for teamwork. Research shows this boosts academic outcomes and reduces behavioral issues, creating a classroom where kids thrive.
Executive Functioning: Students need skills to manage their learning, like planning, prioritizing, and self-monitoring. Teaching these explicitly—perhaps by modeling how to break a project into steps or using checklists—empowers kids to take ownership. This isn’t hand-holding; it’s scaffolding toward independence.
These aren’t extras or babysitting tactics—they’re the core of teaching smarter in an increasingly neurodiverse world, ensuring every child can access and apply the curriculum.
How to Talk to Teachers Who Say This
When a teacher says, “I’m here to teach, not babysit,” it’s often a cry of exasperation—a reflection of burnout, systemic pressures, or a belief that their job is content delivery alone. Engaging them means framing these four areas as a clear, practical framework to enhance—not replace—their work. Here’s how, with gentleness, firmness, and insight:
Start with Empathy: “I hear you—it’s tough when it feels like the system expects you to do it all. Teaching is already such a big job.” This validates their frustration and opens the door.
Reframe the Role Gently: “What if we looked at teaching through four lenses that make your job easier? Like tweaking how you explain things to connect better, or showing kids how to link ideas—it’s still teaching, just smarter.” This introduces the framework as an ally, not a burden.
Point to the Four Areas Firmly: “Kids need more than content. Four things make the difference: communication that clicks for them, cognitive tricks like tying lessons to their lives, emotional support for resilience, and tools to manage their work. Skip these, and they miss out—not because they’re lazy, but because they need us to guide them there.” This lays out the areas clearly and ties them to student success.
Offer a Bridge: “Pick one to try—like asking kids how a lesson connects to what they know. It’s not extra work; it’s redirecting what you already do.” This makes it actionable, starting small with one of the four.
There is a difference between teaching at kids and teaching kids: While some kids have or develop a passion for a subject, many (perhaps most) learn through connection of key concepts and ideas. We have all had people talk "at us" with no space for dialogue or connection, and we know how that makes us feel- annoyed, tired, bored, and disconnected. Instead of seeing yourself as a "content deliverer", see yourself as a "content connector".
The goal is to present these four areas—communication, cognitive strategies, social-emotional growth, and executive functioning—as a roadmap, not a critique. Teachers under pressure may resist, but a gentle push toward this framework can reframe their role as both manageable and impactful.
A Call for Change
Let me be clear: The shift from teaching at kids to teaching kids is not about lowering standards—it’s about redefining success through four key areas: communication that connects, cognitive strategies like conceptual transfer, social-emotional resilience, and executive functioning. This requires training, resources, and a cultural pivot—one that values flexibility and empathy alongside test scores.
So, the next time a teacher says, “I’m here to teach, not babysit,” challenge the subtext—kindly but firmly—with this framework in hand. Teaching isn’t just about content—it’s about empowering the student with the skills to learn, grow, and thrive. It’s time to stop talking at students and start teaching to them, with all the nuance, care, and skill that entails.
Interested In Learning More?
Subscribe to this newsletter!
Check out my appearance on The Neurodiversity Podcast where I discuss how to teach students in today's world.
I wrote a book called Universal Best Practices For All Learners that's available on Amazon
Email or message me.
